904-257-3673 
contact@liebermanfirm.com 
By Andy Lieberman, Florida Bar Board Certified Real Estate Attorney | Lieberman Chamberlain PLLC, Jacksonville | Updated September 25, 2026
The Short Answer
Yes. A quit claim deed can be contested in Florida, but only for a legal defect, not because someone regrets the transfer. The strongest grounds are forgery, fraud, undue influence, lack of mental capacity, a deed never actually delivered, a homestead transfer signed without the spouse, and missing witnesses.
Challenges are brought in circuit court, usually as a quiet title or cancellation-of-deed lawsuit. A forged deed is void and can be attacked at any time; most other claims face deadlines of four to seven years, and waiting can cost you the case.
Most quit claim deeds in Florida are signed at a kitchen table, not a closing table. A parent adds a child to the title. A spouse signs away an interest during a divorce. A sibling “cleans up” the title after a funeral. The document is short, the form is easy to find online, and nobody involved expects a fight.
The fights come later, often after the person who signed has died or lost capacity, when relatives discover a deed they never knew about. This guide explains what actually makes a Florida quit claim deed invalid, which lawsuits are used to undo one, how the deadlines work, and what changes when the grantor has passed away.
A quit claim deed transfers whatever interest the grantor has in the property at the moment of signing, and nothing more. If the grantor owns the whole property, the grantee gets the whole property. If the grantor owns half, or nothing, that is what passes. The grantor makes no promise that the title is good or free of liens.
That is the key difference from a warranty deed. A Florida warranty deed carries covenants that the grantor owns the property, has the right to convey it, and will defend the title against lawful claims. If a title problem surfaces, the grantee can sue the grantor on those promises. With a quit claim deed, there is nothing to sue on.
One common misunderstanding is worth clearing up: a quit claim deed is not weaker at transferring ownership. If the grantor owns the property free and clear, a properly signed quit claim deed conveys it just as completely as a warranty deed. The weakness is in the protection it gives the grantee, not in the transfer itself.
Before looking at how to attack a deed, it helps to know what a valid one requires. Florida’s rules come from a few different statutes, and they serve different purposes:
Recording is where people often get confused. A deed does not have to be recorded to be valid between the grantor and grantee. Recording under section 695.01 protects the grantee against later buyers and creditors who had no notice of the transfer. So an unrecorded deed can still be real, and a recorded deed can still be void.
Courts draw a sharp line between deeds that are void (legally nothing from the start) and deeds that are voidable (valid until a court sets them aside). The difference controls deadlines, what happens to later buyers, and how hard the case is to win.
A forged deed is void. It passes no title, even to a later buyer who paid fair value and had no idea. The same goes for a deed altered after signing in a way that changes its substance, such as swapping the grantee’s name. Expect a handwriting expert, the notary’s journal, and the witnesses’ testimony to become central evidence.
Fraud is different from forgery. Here the grantor really did sign, but only because someone lied about what the document was or what would happen. The Florida Supreme Court in Reed v. Fain treated a deed obtained by fraud as voidable rather than void, which means the claim must be brought in time and can be affected by the rights of innocent later purchasers.
This is the most common ground in family deed disputes, and the reason many quit claim deed undue influence cases in Florida are winnable despite little direct evidence. Florida courts apply a presumption of undue influence, drawn from In re Estate of Carpenter, 253 So. 2d 697 (Fla. 1971), when the person who benefited from the deed had a confidential relationship with the grantor and was active in procuring it. As The Florida Bar Journal explains, active procurement can be shown through facts such as the beneficiary choosing the lawyer, arranging the signing, being present when it happened, and keeping the deed afterward. Once the presumption arises, the grantee has to come forward with a reasonable explanation.
The grantor must understand, at the moment of signing, that they are giving away property, what property it is, and who is receiving it. Dementia, heavy medication, or a serious illness does not automatically void a deed, because people have lucid periods. Medical records from the days around the signing usually decide these cases. A deed signed by someone already adjudicated incapacitated, with those rights removed, stands on much weaker ground.
Florida’s homestead protections in Article X, Section 4 of the Florida Constitution restrict how a married owner can transfer the family home. A married owner generally cannot convey homestead property unless the spouse joins in the deed. A quit claim deed of homestead signed by one spouse alone can be invalid, which matters in second marriages where a parent deeds the home to children without the current spouse’s signature.
A deed without two witnesses fails section 689.01. There is an important catch, though: under section 95.231, once a deed has been of record for five years, defects such as missing witnesses or a flawed acknowledgment are generally cured, absent fraud, adverse possession, or pending litigation. Delivery problems are different, and they often come up in after-death disputes, discussed below.
Challenging a quit claim deed in Florida means filing suit in the circuit court for the county where the property sits. The legal vehicle depends on what you are trying to fix.
Two practical steps matter early. First, record a notice of lis pendens under section 48.23 when the suit is filed, so no one can sell or mortgage the property out from under the case. Second, pull a full title search before filing. Knowing every recorded instrument, mortgage, and lien on the property shapes who must be named as a defendant, and a title search attorney can often spot problems a quick online records search misses.
There is no single deadline. The time limit depends on the legal theory, and some commonly repeated figures online are wrong. Here is how the main rules actually work:
Because the right deadline depends on how the claim is framed, and courts sometimes disagree on which period applies to equitable claims, assume the shortest plausible period and move quickly.
A matter handled by Lieberman Chamberlain PLLC shows how these rules play out in real families. A widowed Arlington homeowner had long told her three children the house would be split equally. In her final months, one son moved in as her caregiver. After she died, the other two siblings learned a quit claim deed had been recorded two weeks after the funeral, transferring the home solely to the caregiver son.
The deed was dated about five weeks before her death, while she was hospitalized. The son had arranged the notary visit and brought two of his friends as witnesses, and he had kept the original deed at the house. Those facts lined up closely with the active-procurement factors Florida courts look for under the undue influence presumption. Hospital records also showed she was on medication that affected her orientation during that period.
Andy Lieberman filed a quiet title and cancellation action in Duval County on behalf of the two siblings and recorded a lis pendens the same day, which stopped a pending sale the son had already listed. Faced with the presumption and the medical records, the son agreed to a stipulated judgment setting the deed aside, and the house passed through the mother’s estate in equal shares as she had said she wanted.
Client details have been changed to protect confidentiality. Every case depends on its own facts, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Yes, and this is when most challenges happen. The personal representative of the estate, and often heirs or beneficiaries who would have received the property, can bring the claim. A few issues come up again and again:
Yes. Forgery, fraud, undue influence, incapacity, and homestead defects can undo any Florida deed, whether it is a warranty deed, special warranty deed, or quit claim deed. The difference is what happens afterward. A grantee under a warranty deed who loses title to a third party’s superior claim may have a claim against the grantor on the warranty and, usually, coverage under an owner’s title insurance policy. A quit claim grantee usually has neither, which is why buyers in arm’s-length sales almost never accept one.
If you are signing or accepting a quit claim deed, a few precautions prevent most of the disputes described above. Use independent witnesses who are not beneficiaries. If the grantor is elderly or ill, have a lawyer meet with them privately, and consider a note from their physician close to the signing date. Confirm homestead status and get the spouse’s joinder where required. Record promptly. And if you suspect someone may try to transfer your property without your knowledge, many Florida clerks now offer free property fraud alert services that notify owners when a document is recorded in their name.
Not on that basis alone. Once a valid deed is signed, witnessed, and delivered, the grantor cannot revoke it. The grantee would have to sign a new deed conveying the property back.
Lack of notice is not itself a ground to void a deed, but it often goes hand in hand with fraud or undue influence, and it can affect when the fraud limitations period starts to run.
The court cancels the deed and title returns to where it stood before the transfer. If the grantor has died, the property typically passes through the estate or to whoever held title under the prior deed. The court can also address mortgages or liens the grantee placed on the property, depending on the facts.
Between the parties, the notary is not what makes a deed valid; the two witnesses are. But the clerk will not record an unacknowledged deed, and an unrecorded deed leaves the grantee exposed to later purchasers and creditors.
It depends heavily on whether the other side fights. Some cases resolve with a corrective or reconveyance deed after a demand letter; others go through discovery, expert witnesses, and trial. Ask any attorney you consult for a realistic estimate based on the evidence available.
This article provides general information about Florida law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with Lieberman Chamberlain PLLC. Deed disputes turn on specific facts and strict deadlines, and the law may change after publication. If you believe a deed affecting your property or a loved one’s estate is invalid, speak with a licensed Florida attorney promptly about your situation.
Andy Lieberman is a Florida Bar Board Certified Real Estate Attorney at Lieberman Chamberlain PLLC in Jacksonville, where he handles quiet title actions, deed disputes, and title defects for families, investors, and lenders. His more than twenty years of practice include serving as counsel to a national title insurance underwriter and owning Florida title agencies, experience that shapes how he reads a chain of title. He began his career as an Assistant Public Defender, trying cases before juries.
Based on 253 reviews
Andy and Harbor View Title have earned our trust through numerous real estate closings, from PSA review to title search examinations, insurance, and closings. At every stage, Andy and his team provided excellent, timely and cost-effective counsel. Their attention to detail and timely responses made each transaction smooth and efficient. I can strongly recommend Andy to anyone in need of real estate legal assistance.
Andy has been great to work with. He provides timely updates and explains things clearly. He is very knowledgeable and levelheaded, which is exactly what we need most times. I highly recommend him if you need legal assistance in Northeast Florida.
Worked with Lieberman Chamberlain on real estate transaction involving substantive redlines.
Andrew was responsive, thorough, and precise in his analysis, with clear communication throughout the process. Issues were identified early, addressed timely, and efficiently, with no details overlooked.
I would confidently recommend their services.
Lieberman Chamberlain is top-notch when it comes to real estate. Their team is incredibly knowledgeable and true experts in the field. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for a trusted advisor in the industry.
Don’t face your legal challenges alone. Whether you need a real estate lawyer, a personal injury attorney, or a commercial lending expert, the team at Lieberman Chamberlain PLLC is ready to help.
Call us at 904-257-3673 or fill out our online form to schedule a confidential consultation.
